When the give-way vessel does nothing
Stand-on vessel action. Advanced level, about 3 min. International COLREGs / IRPCS. COLREGs Rule 17.
The situation
Kestrel, a power-driven vessel, is crossing from your port side on a steady bearing. Both vessels are in sight of one another in open water, and you are under power.
What do you do first?
- Keep your course and speed: You are the stand-on vessel. Keep watching her.
- Alter to port now to pass astern of her: Get out of the situation early.
- Alter to starboard now, just to be safe: Open the distance before it gets close.
Answers and explanations
Lookout: A stand-on vessel keeps course and speed at first, but the duty to avoid collision never lapses. Watch for the moment when the other vessel alone can no longer avoid it.
When the situation changes
Kestrel still has not altered. You sounded five short blasts; there is no response, the bearing has not moved and the range is closing fast.
Turn hard to starboard, away from her
Once it is apparent that the give-way vessel is not taking appropriate action you may act, and when collision can no longer be avoided by her action alone you must. A hard turn to starboard, away from a vessel on your port side, is the action that best aids avoiding collision here.
Keep standing on
Standing on was right at first, but Rule 17(b) requires you to take the action that best aids avoiding collision once she alone cannot avoid it. Holding on at this range leaves the outcome to her.
Turn to port, towards her stern
Rule 17(c): a power-driven vessel acting in a crossing situation should, if the circumstances admit, not alter course to port for a vessel on her own port side. A late starboard turn by her would bring the two of you together.
The sound answer
Keep your course and speed
Rule 17(a)(i): with Kestrel on your port side, you are the stand-on vessel and keep your course and speed, so she can rely on you while she gives way.
Why the other options fall short
Alter to port now to pass astern of her
As the stand-on vessel you keep your course and speed at this stage. Kestrel does what the rules expect of her and turns to starboard to pass astern of you, straight into your port turn.
Alter to starboard now, just to be safe
Rule 17(a)(i): the stand-on vessel keeps her course and speed. An early alteration takes away the predictability Kestrel is relying on. It worked out here only because she turned to starboard too; it may not next time.
Rule 17 · Action by stand-on vessel
The stand-on vessel keeps course and speed, may act once the give-way vessel is clearly not doing so, and must act when collision cannot be avoided by the give-way vessel alone. In a crossing situation she avoids turning to port for a vessel on her own port side.