Power meets sail
Different vessel responsibilities. Foundation level, about 3 min. International COLREGs / IRPCS. COLREGs Rule 18.
The situation
You are under power. A sailing vessel, using sails only, crosses from your port side. This is open water, outside a narrow channel or traffic separation scheme, and you are not overtaking.
Which vessel should keep out of the way?
- Alter boldly to port and pass astern of her: Swing well round to cross behind the yacht.
- Maintain course and speed: Treat the vessel on your port side as give-way.
- Alter a little to starboard: Give her a bit more room ahead of you.
Answers and explanations
Lookout: Identify the vessel’s operating state. A sailing hull using machinery is a power-driven vessel for these rules.
The sound answer
Alter boldly to port and pass astern of her
In the stated circumstances a power-driven vessel keeps out of the way of a sailing vessel. She is the stand-on vessel and will hold her course, so a bold, early alteration to port takes you clear astern of her. Make it large enough that she sees it at once.
Why the other options fall short
Maintain course and speed
Rule 15 concerns two power-driven vessels. Here the other vessel is sailing, and the stated conditions allow Rule 18’s power-driven vessel responsibility to apply.
Alter a little to starboard
A small starboard alteration keeps you converging with her and tries to cross ahead of a vessel you must keep clear of. Rule 8 asks for an alteration large enough to be readily apparent, and Rule 15’s spirit is to pass astern, not ahead.
Rule 18 · Responsibilities between vessels
Subject to the exceptions in Rules 9, 10 and 13, a power-driven vessel underway keeps out of the way of a sailing vessel. The operating state and context matter.